Christmas 2025 FAQ

The Store will be open, but the bakery will be closed on the 21st for Christmas Order prep.

As usual we will be offering pickup on the 22nd, 23rd, and 24th of December, this year that will be Monday-Wednesday.

We will be open 9 am - 6 pm on the 22nd and 23rd, and from 9 am - 5 pm on the 24th. We are asking to have all orders on the 24th be picked up by 3 pm, to allow any unclaimed pies to be released for sale to the general public at 4 pm.

As usual dinner rolls will only be available on Wednesday the 24th.

As usual we accept Christmas Orders from December 3rd until Saturday December 20th.

As a part of our Holiday celebration we’ll be making DONUTS! on Wednesday Dec. 24th.

Hot and Fresh off the machine from 9 am - noon.

We only accept Christmas Orders via telephone (607-835-6455) or in person.

The pie selection available for Christmas Pickup will be the same as in the past: Apple, Dutch Apple, Pumpkin, Blueberry, Dutch Blueberry, Cherry, Dutch Cherry, Pecan, Mince, and our No Sugar Added Apple. Our version of a traditional Polish Babka will be available all three days. Available on Wednesday only (12/24) are Jaime’s Famous Dinner Rolls.

We’ll be closed from December 25th through January 13th.

As always, no exceptions

Even Grandma Hollenbeck had to follow these rules to get her pie, babka, and rolls.